If it’s only the cover that I see, I would probably have stayed away from this one, but I’ve already read two other books by this author (see the reviews here: ‘Running From Scissors’ and here: ‘Slay Bells: A Christmas Village Mystery’), and I really liked those, so I decided to ignore it.
Let’s see how it worked out!
I got this book from BooksGoSocial and NetGalley in exchange for my honest and unbiased opinion.
Discovery:
I was actually waiting for this one to be available on NetGalley, since I really enjoyed the first book in the series. It had an old-timey feeling with the structure similar to a classic crime story, and I couldn’t wait to read about the characters again. Especially Ruby, the old lady so much like in the old stories I like so much. So this one was a must-read for me.
Brainstorm:
I enjoyed this book, too, though not as much as I expected I would. The characters are more or less the same, and I like the ones that were introduced in this one (At least as characters. Some of them not as people.) The style is basically the same, so there’s not much I can say about that. It might have been improved a little bit. I feel like it did, but I can’t put my finger on what exactly makes me feel like this, so it remains a feeling.
These are the things I expected.
I’m not so sure about the story, though. After I read the ending, and learned everything about all the connections between the events, I thought it was pretty clever – but I was surprised it was clever, and I don’t think that’s so flattering. I mean, reading this book my interest kept going and coming back, because that’s how much I didn’t think about one storyline while reading about the other. There was also an escape room scene which could’ve been very interesting, had it some connection to the real mystery, but it really didn’t have, thus making it simply a distraction from what would’ve been interesting. I still think I would’ve loved it, if it were a bit shorter – half a chapter, maybe one. Not more. I think this was in itself a very good story, but the pacing was a bit off in this one.
The other reason I wasn’t so enthusiastic about this book (as the first one) is more subjective: half the book dealt with Valentine’s Day stuff, and unfortunately that’s something that I hate. This hype about V-Day, I mean. I hate that half the world goes totally crazy over it, that you must have a date, unless I don’t know what, I hate how cheesy and not honest it is. So, obviously, I wasn’t a big fan of the fact that the characters I otherwise like feel like this is such big an event. The scene where Lacy waits for the revelation who her ‘secret admirer’ is was one I felt like I was watching a movie straight out of Hollywood, and that’s not something I like. At all.
Well, that sounds like I didn’t like this book at all, which is not true! I did, it’s just so much easier to talk about the things that bother me… It’s all in comparison to the first book, which I rated 4.5.
Let’s Give It A Grade!
- Story: 3/5
- Characters: 4/5
- Style: 4/5
- The Subjective Factor: 4/5
- GPA: 3.75
Uniqueness:
The dragged-out revelation with everybody important sitting there and waiting for the verdict is a very good imitation of Golden Age crime fiction. Otherwise, I don’t think this one is very different from other books in the genre. Or by the author.
Recommend to:
Give this one a try if you like both cozy and classic mysteries. I’d say to read the first book, ‘Running from Scissors’ before you read this one, though. It’s okay to read as a standalone, I think, it would be completely understandable, but I think it’s worth knowing the characters and the little town a bit better before jumping into this one.
Drink tip:
Cosmopolitan. (Because of the taste, not the name, of course!)
Music room:
‘Playing with my Heart’ by Kate Voegele. Yes, it’s almost purely because of the Valentine’s Day topic.
Future:
I will follow this series forward! (If there’s any more books to come.)
Have you read this book, or the others written by Wescott? What did you think?
Have a great day!
Hugs 🙂
Not read this, but Valentine has become just another excuse for commercial madness, so it probably wouldn’t be my favourite.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yepp… I would’ve enjoyed it more if it was set at another time of the year..
LikeLike
I haven’t read this book yet. But I have seen a lot of mixed opinions about this one. Escape room scene is something that everybody’s commenting on – not related to the story.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m very curious about what you’re going to think about it! That scene in itself was actually good in my opinion, but this way it was completely unnecessary. I think it should’ve been shorter and should have had a strong connection to the story, then it would’ve been awesome. This way, not so much.
LikeLike
I am very curious to read about the escape room. You mentioned it, and so did Anjana and Shalini in their reviews. I will start the book next week. Let’s see 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, I’ve seen their reviews, too 😊 can’t wait for yours 😉
LikeLike
Hahaha I have read it… I am sure author has banned me
But I am do happy you loved it.. Perfect review 😍
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks! 😊 Well, I wouldn’t say loved it, but I liked it, yeah… I hate when authors act like that… I know it must feel bad to see negative reviews, but they should know there’s just no way everybody will like their writing. I’ve read your review, and it wasn’t even that bad. You actually said positive things, too. I don’t know when a 3-star rating became such a negative review… It’s definitely not one that should make somebody feel hurt…
LikeLike
Well I find the ways of murder ingenious… 😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
😂😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cozies do get a bit distracted!!! Though an escape room scene sounds fun 💕 Great review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, I know, it was just a bit much for me in this one! 😅 I liked it, though. It was superfun, I just thought the length would’ve been way more appropriate if it was at least a bit connected to the main story! 😀 Thank you! ❤️
LikeLike
A very detailed review, Dora! Well done! Think I’ll skip this one, though 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you! 😊 I liked it, even in spite of these things that bothered me, but yeah, I’m sure it’s not for everyone. 😅 This Valentine’s Day stuff made it harder to enjoy for me, too…
LikeLike